Words: Miljan Milekić
It may sound weird, but my brain was always processing music differently depending on the time of year. Every band has its season when their music hits the hardest. Granted, I will see the band I love every chance I get, but when it all clicks together, it gets so much better. The Menzingers and Hot Water Music on a cold November night? Where do I sign?
The night actually started with Maine’s Weakened Friends, who we sadly missed. The band is still riding the waves of last year’s album ‘Feels Like Hell,’ so there’s zero doubt in my mind they delivered a great show.
We did, however, come just in time to see Hot Water Music, a band I’ve been obsessed with since the first time I heard ‘Exister’ back in 2012. They have been high on my list of bands to see live for more than a decade, and yet, until now, they kept eluding me. And the moment the quartet stepped on the stage, I knew it was worth the wait.
Right off the bat, they kicked things off with ‘Remedy,’ before quickly slipping into ‘A Flight and A Crash’ and ‘State Of Grace.’ At that point, it was clear that we’re in for a speedrun of heavy hitters. ‘Habitual’ and ‘Turn the Dial’ followed, before the band briefly slowed down with ‘After the Impossible,’ during which I caught myself glancing towards the side stage if a certain person with a colour and a city in his name would mysteriously appear from the dark.
‘Burn Forever’ and ‘Fences’ followed, before a short break during which the band introduced ‘No Division.’ Chris Cresswell addressed the state of the world today, the results of the recent midterm election in the US, and, being Canadian himself, the struggles Indigenous people in Canada still face in this day and age.
As their set was coming to an end, they delivered three absolute ragers in ‘Drag My Body,’ ‘Menace,’ and ‘Trusty Chords.’ Chuck Ragan is possibly one of the most unique and powerful voices in punk and hardcore, both vocally and lyrically, while the addition of Cresswell infuses an additional dose of infectious melodies and a slightly different poetic sensibility. I loved the way it clicked on records, especially ‘Vows,’ and I loved the way it worked on stage. Now it’s time to catch them on a headline show somewhere.
Dear diary, I have a confession to make. I didn’t really like The Menzingers when I first heard them. I can’t explain why – I could tell they were a great band, they checked all the boxes, and my punk-listening friends were all in love with ‘On the Impossible Past,’ but I just didn’t get it. It was with ‘Rented World,’ and especially ‘After the Party, ’ that it all started to change.
It was ‘I Don’t Wanna Be an Asshole Anymore’ and ‘In Remission’ that lit up my love for the band, and I was happy to hear both songs played on the night. But I’m getting ahead of myself. The band is currently touring their new record ‘Everything I Ever Saw,’ so there was no surprise when they kicked things off with the album’s opener ‘Chance Encounters.’ Despite it being released just a few months ago, it definitely didn’t feel that way, as the song immediately triggered a massive singalong, which seamlessly transitioned into an even bigger one for ‘The Obituaries.’
Once the tone was set, the rest of the night couldn’t go wrong. Tom May and Greg Barnett were trading singing duties throughout the night, each practically having about a thousand backing vocals, picking and choosing songs from (almost) their whole career. ‘Tellin’ Lies,’ ‘I Don’t Wanna Be an Asshole Anymore,’ ‘Lookers,’ ‘Anna,’ and ‘Good Things’ are all well-established fan favorites, while ‘Better Angels’ is slowly but surely joining them in that status. This part of the set also brought the biggest throwback of the night with the cover of ‘Straight to Hell,’ by The Clash, which band released on their debut back in 2007.
The late stages of the set brought ‘America (You’re Freaking Me Out),’ and ‘Burn After Writing,’ as well as two more new songs that are likely to become staples in the band’s shows in the future – ‘Nobody’s Heroes’ and ‘Everything I Ever Saw,’ which closed the first part of their set. The encore was brief, but very loud, with ‘Hope Is a Dangerous Little Thing’ and finally ‘After the Party.’
At the beginning, I mentioned the weather and the time of the year. Add in one more factor that made this night special – a beautiful, 106-year-old theatre. The contrast of massive concrete walls, old glass chandeliers, and modern stage equipment seamlessly blends eras. Both The Menzingers and Hot Water Music draw a lot from the artists that came before them, throughout different times in rock and punk history, mixing it with modern influences and their own signature sound. And I couldn’t imagine a place that better matched that energy.

